Tuesday, September 17, 2019
Sample Essay â⬠The Role of Women Essay
The transition from early 19th century England to late 20th century Australia reveals an overwhelming shift in the dominant discourses and ideologies surrounding the role of women. While Jane Austen composed her seminal 1813 romance Pride and Prejudice against the social and historical backdrop of Regency England, a time when patriarchal ideals governed notions of femininity, Fay Weldonââ¬â¢s 1984 epistolary novel Letters to Alice bears the hallmarks of post-feminist womenââ¬â¢s liberation and agency. However, through close examination of the intertextual connections woven between this pair of texts, it emerges that not only does Weldonââ¬â¢s text take form as a didactic treatise to her young nice that reflects her own contemporary views on women and women writers, her letters prompt an unquestioningly feminist re-reading of Austenââ¬â¢s representation of women in her own literary works. As a result, it is these connections that yield the recognition that despite the contextual divide separating this pair of texts, both authors are irrevocably bound in their purpose to didactically challenge the politically charged representation and role of women in their respective cultural spheres. Composed in the late 20th century ââ¬â an era where feminist discourses of equality were deeply entrenched in political and academic spheres ââ¬â Weldonââ¬â¢s text is narratively shaped as a didactic novel addressed to her fictionalised ââ¬Ëgreen haired punkââ¬â¢ niece, using the epistolary form to both instruct and demonstrate the power of literature ââ¬Å"with its capital Lâ⬠to function as a vehicle for women to both change and challenge dominant social conventions and values. To achieve these means, it is no coincidence that Weldon is seen to appropriate the epistolary form ââ¬â ââ¬Å"a popular form of fiction at the timeâ⬠used by female writers such as Austen herself- to create a intertextual connection that transcends the contextual gap separating each text to promote a specifically feminist view of writers and the function of ââ¬Å"Literatureâ⬠. Here, Weldon is herself the embodiment of her self-described breed of ââ¬Å"strong women, wo men who work, think, earn, have independent habitsâ⬠. Her authoritative didacticisms to the burgeoning writer Alice -ââ¬Å"simply speakâ⬠¦and you will be listened to. And eventually,à even enjoy your captive audienceâ⬠ââ¬â symbolically demonstrate the legacy of feminist ideals that were initially catalysed through early Regency female authors such as Austen whose patriarchal context kept their revolutionary works ââ¬Å"shelter[ed] behind the cloak of anonymityâ⬠. Given the modern context of Letters to Alice, it is undeniable that Weldon writes from a discourse of female agency when she informs Alice that to enter the ââ¬Å"immortalâ⬠ââ¬Å"City of Inventionâ⬠, she must metaphorically ââ¬Å"swim against the stream of communal ideasâ⬠and ââ¬Å"demonstrate to the reader the limitations of conventionâ⬠that societies inscribe upon its populace as ââ¬Å"unquestioned beliefsâ⬠. The strong tone employed in such directives highlight that from Weldonââ¬â¢s feminist perspective, the value of female authorship and literature is derived from the capacity of oneââ¬â¢s own personal value system to morally guide or catalyse a transformation in its readership: ââ¬Å"Readers need and seek moral guidanceâ⬠¦They need an example, in the light of which they can examine themselves, [and] understand themselves.â⬠Simply put, Weldonââ¬â¢s Letters to Alice is a text that is highly political in purpose; it prompts a strong consideration of the function of literature to catalyse notions of female empowerment through both changing and challenging dominant social conventions and values. Taking into account Weldonââ¬â¢s didacticisms regarding female authorship and social change, it becomes apparent that the intertextual connections to Jane Austen weaved within Letters to Alice prompt an undeniably feminist re-evaluation of her representation of Elizabeth Bennet in Pride and Prejudice. While separated by the historical divide of almost two centuries, Weldonââ¬â¢s instruction for her niece to ââ¬Å"swim against the stream of communal ideasâ⬠can be seen to resonate in Austenââ¬â¢s idealistic protagonist Elizabeth Bennet, a character who transgresses against the dominant values that governed Regency England; and whose personal virtues triumphed over the restrictions of her era. Weldonââ¬â¢s didactic assertion that female authorââ¬â¢s must work to ââ¬Å"demonstrate to the reader the limitations of conventionâ⬠undeniably connect with and transform perceptions of Austenââ¬â¢s Elizabeth, framing and augmenting her personal values of rationalit y and wit as they shine through the text. This is particularly evident through her strong authoritative tone in declarative statements: ââ¬Å"I shall be very fit to seeà Jane ââ¬â which is all I wantâ⬠, which work alongside uncharacteristic images of female activity: ââ¬Å"springing over puddles to with impatient activity [gave her] a face glowing with the warmth of exerciseâ⬠to undermine a social value system that links feminine propriety with explicit passivity. Such aspects of her character are further augmented through Austen inscribing Elizabethââ¬â¢s dialogue with a strongly comedic tone of satire and irony. She delights in intellectually challenging the supposedly superior intellect of Mr Darcy in a series of playful exchanges: ââ¬Å"I am convinced that one good sonnet will stave [love] entirely awayâ⬠; ââ¬Å"your defect is to hate everybodyâ⬠. In considering these connections, Weldonââ¬â¢s text can be seen to invoke a renewed reading of Elizabeth, positioning her as a didactic figure that planted the early seeds of feminist discourse from which Letters to Alice was composed: ââ¬Å"[She] pay[ed] paying attention to the subtle demands of human dignity rather than the cruder ones of established conventionâ⬠¦prodding [civilisation] quicker and faster along the slow difficult road that has led us out of barbarity into civilisationâ⬠Ultimately, examination of the intertextual connections between Letters to Alice and Pride and Prejudice yield a recognition that while Weldonââ¬â¢s text instructs young Alice on contemporary views on women and women writers from a late 19th century context, it also catalyses a re-evaluation of Austenââ¬â¢s representation of Elizabeth Bennet, reframing interpretations of her character as one who challenges the dominant value systems of gender. As a result, it is these connections that incite the realisation that despite the contextual divide separating this pair of texts, both authors are irrevocably bound in their purpose to didactically challenge the politically charged representation and role of women in their respective cultural spheres.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.